The Mechanics of Oreo Twisting

Oreo cookies, beloved for their delicious combination of creamy filling and wafer layers, have become the subject of a scientific study exploring the mechanical mysteries behind their unique properties. Researchers at MIT have delved into the science of Oreo cookies, investigating the distribution of their creamy center, the torque required to twist them open, and the fascinating behavior of the cream under stress.

Torque Measurements and Cream Texture

The researchers measured the torque needed to twist open an Oreo, revealing similarities to turning a doorknob and only a fraction of the force required to open a bottle cap. The cream’s failure stress, the force per area needed to deform it, was found to be twice that of cream cheese and peanut butter, resembling the stress magnitude of mozzarella cheese. The cream’s texture was classified as “mushy.” Adding milk into the equation revealed another layer of scientific wonder. Dunking Oreos in milk resulted in a decline in the elastic modulus of the wafer due to swelling. 

Cream Distribution Mystery

Despite variations in filling levels and flavors, the study found that the cream tends to separate onto one wafer rather than evenly between both. The researchers mapped this distribution and observed a tendency for the cream to stick to the inward-facing wafer, suggesting a post-manufacturing environmental effect.

FIG. 7. (a) While most creme layers failed adhesively in boxes of new cookies, (b) cookies exposed to adverse conditions may cause creme to spread from its initial manufactured state, and then cohesive failure was typical for most cookies in the box. These visual signs of changing creme fill levels (indicated by the black arrows in (a) and (b) are typical but not deterministic predictors of failure mode. (c) Failure tests also distinguished between cases in the computed stress–strain curves resulting from the measured torque as a function of imposed rotation angle. There was a single peak stress for adhesive failure, which occurs as a single delamination step, and two or more maxima in stress for cohesively failing creme layers due to the more complex dynamics of cohesive failure propagation along nonplanar surfaces. Cohesive failure was also typically observed to result in a higher failure strain and lower failure stress, as shown here.

Manufacturing Process Influence

Videos of the manufacturing process revealed that a slight time delay in placing the cream between wafers may contribute to better adhesion to the first wafer, influencing the subsequent distribution during twisting.

FIG. 1. (a) What happens when you twist an Oreo? (b) Eventually it splits into two parts, exposing the creme. (c) and (d) We observed that in a typical failure profile for Oreos from newly opened boxes, the creme most often tends to remain on one side, “wafer 1,” with a consistent orientation per box. In this case, wafer 1 faces to the left side of the upright box for a standard size package of regular Oreos. The creme occasionally splits between sides, often due to defects or small fractures in one or both wafers. (e) This is consistent for cookies with different creme levels, with a strong bias toward wafers facing one side of the box rather than the other, facing left for regular, right for double, and up for mega (where rows are oriented vertically rather than horizontally) in standard size packages.

The Oreometer

To make the study accessible and interactive, the researchers even designed a 3D-printable device called the “Oreometer,” allowing precise control over the twisting force applied to an Oreo. This device can be used for tabletop experiments and provides an opportunity for hands-on exploration of Oreo mechanics.

A 3D printed Oreometer is used to perturb cookies with scientific precision by applying a known and controlled torque. (a) In this device, (1) the cookie is mounted first into one half and then (2) the second half of the rubber band-powered clamps, which are then (3) placed into the vertical assembly mount. (4) “Penny castles” are mounted on the wings, and coins are successively loaded to one side to apply controlled torque until (5) the creme yields. (b) Results replicate values measured by the laboratory rheometer. (c) Photographs demonstrate the same tool, also including the rubber bands in two different arrangements designed to apply different levels of gripping strength in the clamps.

Confectionary Insights

The study not only provides a scientific investigation into the mechanics of Oreos but also opens possibilities for further exploration into the design of food materials. The researchers suggest that adding texture to Oreo wafers might enhance cream adhesion, leading to a more even split when twisted open.

In conclusion, Oreos offer more than just a delightful treat—they serve as a fascinating canvas for exploring the intricate science behind food materials and rheology.

References

Massachusetts Institute of Technology. (2022, April 19). Engineers introduce the Oreometer. ScienceDaily. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2022/04/220419124037.htm

Owens, C. E., Fan, M. R., Hart, A. J., & McKinley, G. H. (2022). On Oreology, the fracture and flow of “milk’s favorite Cookie®.” Physics of Fluids, 34(4). https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0085362

More like this

full moon picture

Does a Full Moon effect our Sleep?

There are many myths surrounding the effects of a full moon on humans from higher rates of...

My Experiences Being a TA for a STEM Class...

  During your time at Georgia Tech, as a STEM major, one of the things that you might...

Treating U87 EGFP Glibolastoma Cells with Nickel Sulfate!

Part of the reward of being a Biomedical Engineer is the opportunity to explore fascinating and cutting-edge...